When construction companies need to hire fast—especially for critical roles like project managers, estimators, or division leaders—many default to contingency search. On the surface, it seems like a no-risk solution: recruiters only get paid if they deliver. But here’s the problem…
Contingency search often fails to produce the results that construction businesses actually need.
In this article, we’ll explain what contingency search is, why it’s broken in the construction industry, and what hiring strategy actually works for securing top-tier talent.
Related: https://hcrc.us/2025/04/optimize-your-hiring-process-with-the-recruitment-audit-checklist/
What Is Contingency Search?
Contingency search is a recruitment model where companies engage one or more recruiters on a “pay-only-if-you-succeed” basis. The recruiter only gets paid if their candidate is hired.
While this model may seem appealing due to its pay-for-performance nature, it creates an environment where speed trumps quality, and quantity often wins over precision.
The Hidden Risks of Contingency Search in Construction
1. Lack of Focus
Contingency recruiters take on multiple roles across various industries to hedge their bets. This means your high-priority search is one of many—and often gets less attention.
2. Rushed, Incomplete Vetting
Because they only get paid if someone gets hired, contingency recruiters are incentivized to move fast. That often leads to rushed candidate submittals with poor screening, limited relationship-building, and minimal understanding of your company culture.
3. Outsourced Recruiting
To scale, many contingency firms use overseas RPOs (Recruitment Process Outsourcing teams) who cold-call candidates with limited industry knowledge and poor communication skills—damaging your employer brand in the process.
4. No Real Partnership
Contingency recruiting is transactional. There’s little strategic planning, no co-branded marketing, and zero commitment to long-term success. Once the hire is made (if one happens), the relationship ends.
Why Retained Search Outperforms Contingency Models
Retained search flips the dynamic. When you partner with a retained search firm, you’re investing in a recruitment team that commits exclusive time, resources, and strategy to fill your role successfully.
Key Benefits of Retained Search:
-
✅ Dedicated Team: A lead consultant, sourcing specialists, recruiters, and marketing experts focused solely on your search.
-
✅ Industry-Specific Knowledge: Especially important in construction where role requirements and cultural fit vary project-to-project.
-
✅ Recruitment Marketing Strategy: Your role is presented with compelling messaging that converts passive candidates.
-
✅ Candidate Relationship-Building: Retained firms take the time to build trust, increasing the chance of securing top talent.
-
✅ Guarantees That Matter: At Heavy Civil Resource Consultants, we offer a tiered 5-year replacement warranty—something unheard of in contingency recruiting.
When Contingency Search Might Still Work
To be fair, contingency search can be useful in certain situations:
-
You’re hiring for entry-level or high-volume roles
-
You need temporary or contract labor
-
You’re testing the market with no urgency to hire
But if you’re hiring for key leadership, project-critical, or specialist roles within construction, contingency recruiting is likely to fall short.
The Bottom Line
Contingency search is popular because it feels low-risk. But for most construction companies, it delivers low reward.
If you’re serious about hiring top-tier talent that drives your revenue and company growth, it’s time to rethink your recruitment strategy. Retained search provides the focus, strategy, and accountability you need to attract and secure the best candidates in today’s competitive market.
Need help with a high-impact construction hire?
Partner with Heavy Civil Resource Consultants—your retained search experts for mid, senior, and executive-level construction roles.
📞 [Contact us today]
